Great stuff!

Perfect idea.

Whole lot to do with thrashing like a maniac.

Metallica has the type of fanbase where this will actually turn out fucking awesome. AC/DC...I'm not sure. Wish they'd come back to the US sometime so I could see them.

A good idea but it won`t happend with AC/DC. Sorry to say it but they are too narrow minded.

I just hope to see them in concert again. I won`t complain about the set list. They can play whatever songs they like.
But please, one more album and tour.

the reality is if you leave it to the fans (not just people on here) we would have ended up with a similar setlist that we got on the BI tour

90% of the people who bought tickets to the Black Ice Tour were probably satisfied with the set list.

They play what the average concert goer like and not what a few hardcore fans like to hear.

^ too true. I know people who love the band every bit as much as we all do and they didnt utter one word of complaint. Those shows were everything they wanted them to be

Posted By: JemIf you have a look around the internet at various polls you might be surprised at what shows up after the top ten most obvious e.g.

http://www.thetopten...

wow.................

Honestly, I enjoyed every bit of my show too and didn't have one complaint and I still don't. I wish I would've been a tad older and had known more about the band like I do now. So I'm more angry at myself rather than the band lol. Plus I would've liked better seats but I didn't buy the tix, my dad did. Next time, if there is a next time, it will be different. If I ever see the band again, sure my fingers will be crossed for just one song that wasn't played on the BI tour but if it is exactly the same I wouldn't care.

On the other hand you would get from the top 20

LWTTT
R'n'RANP
Moneytalks
Jailbreak
If You Want Blood
SUL
High Voltage

And that would liven up the setlist!

I missed out Big Balls. Because I am not a cunt.

Posted By: carlos fandangothe reality is if you leave it to the fans (not just people on here) we would have ended up with a similar setlist that we got on the BI tour

Fair comment - so let's see what the Metallica fans (which I'm sure includes some folk on here), come up with. Who thinks it will be a greatest hits set ala AC/DC? And who thinks the set lists will be identical every night of these tour dates?

I can think of maybe 3 songs post AJFA that I might pick. Enter Sandman isn't one of them.

Whiplash
For Whom The Bell Tolls
Fade To Black
Creeping Death
Master Of Puppets
Sanitarium
Disposable Heroes
Leper Messiah
Damage Inc.
Blackened
And Justice For All
Eye Of The Beholder
Harvester Of Sorrow
Seek And Destroy
Sad But True
The Unforgiven

Is probably it. Ish

I thought about King Nothing and I Disappear.

In what way?

Just Metallica or the thrash scene in general?

Ditto. Soft spot for early Metallica/Anthrax.

LOVE Early Metallica. Listening to In Justice For All blasting...What an experience, too bad there is no bass in the mix lol. Ride The Lightning is also up there. I was never a big thrash metal either but as Jem, said I have a soft spot for Metallica.

Kill'Em All is probably the best album Metallica ever put out. Nothing else lives up to it for me.

The bass player in me wants to hate AJFA, but the metalhead in me thinks its their best album. Dyer's Eve. Seriously.

Megadeth never did anything for me. Dave's voice was too whiny and I didn't even enjoy his guitar playing.